Top 10 Lists

Top 10 Cigars of 2015 – Tony Casas Edition

By  | 

It’s that time of the year again folks. The time where the cigar community sits down to iron out what they thought were the best cigars of 2015. Sure, we didn’t smoke everything new, but that’s part of the fun. Seeing which cigars did or did not make the cut. Here at Casas Fumando we don’t claim to be the best in the business, nor do we take ourselves very serious. We’re just a couple of guys who like to smoke cigars, so our very subjective lists reflect that. Enough talking, let’s get to this.

#10 Caldwell – Blind Man’s Bluff

Caldwell Blind Man's Bluff

Caldwell’s Blind Man’s Bluff is another great cigar from the company. They came flying out of the gate and haven’t slowed down. Add the price of this cigar in comparison to the other cigars in Caldwell’s portfolio into the equation and it’s easy to see why this cigar has been so popular amongst the cigar community. The flavors, full body, marketing, and price all lured me towards this cigar. Not to mention Caldwell’s track record, and it impressed me out of the gate. This may be a bit too full bodied for the novice cigar smoker, but it would fit in perfectly with one who wants to venture into full-bodied premium cigars without breaking the bank. On the flip side, and seasoned cigar smoker looking for a great, solid, reasonably priced cigar should be all over these. I plan on picking up a box as this is something I could easily see being a long-time contender in my daily rotation.

Full Review Here

#9 Foundation Cigar Company – El Güegüense

El Gueguense

I’ve smoked a handful of these and have been impressed each run. The flavor profile is awesome, solid, and consistent while the price point is right where it should be. This is a perfect cigar for novice cigar smokers looking for a great full-bodied cigar that isn’t too powerful nor will it break the bank. It’s also perfect for those seasoned smokers looking for a solid, full-bodied stick to add to their regular rotation. Box worthy for sure.

Full Review Here

#8 Drew Estate – Undercrown Shade

Drew Estate Undercrown Shade

In the last few years some great Connecticut wrapped cigars have crashed into the cigar world, the Undercrown Shade is amongst the best. I was once very wary of Connecticut wrapped cigars, but the manufacturers have really done a bang up job creating blends utilizing this wrapper that remain bolder, yet balanced and the Undwecrown Shade is a perfect example of that. While it’s on the very mild side of medium/full, the cigar showcased some great flavors, a perfect burning experience, all at a great price. Not really much more you can ask for there. This is perfect for the novice smoker looking for a premium cigar that won’t overpower them with strength or body. And us seasoned smokers ca really appreciate the cigar as well. I’ll be sure to keep quite a few of these around for those times when I’m looking for something that delivers on flavors, but isn’t quite as strong as some of the other cigars in my rotation.

Full Review Here

#7 Quesada – Oktoberfest 2015 Double Bock Nicaraguan

Quesada Oktoberfest Double Bock

The departure from the Dominican Republic was a success with the Double Bock blend. The cigar was complex, yet relaxed and made for a full body experience without being too overpowering. The price is perfect for the cigar and in my opinion, may even be less than I’d expect to pay for it. This is a perfect cigar for a novice looking for some great work without breaking the bank, and of course us seasoned cigar smokers looking for a great full-bodied cigar that won’t knock us on our ass will love it. Box worthy for sure.

Full Review Here

#6 La For Dominicana – La Nox

La Flor Dominicana LFD La Nox

La Nox is quite a departure from what we normally expect from La Flor Dominicana, and it served as a breath of fresh air. Not that LFD’s stuff is bad by any means, I quite enjoy their offerings. What I mean is, it’s nice to see them step out of their element a bit, and they killed it. La Nox is a deep, rich, bold, flavor bomb that hits on all marks. The fact that it’s full production makes it that much more desirable. The price is a bit steep, but I can honestly say that it delivered and the price is well worth it.

Full Review Here

#5 RoMa Craft Tobac – Neanderthal

RoMa Craft Tobac Neanderthal

Skip has just added to an already stacked arsenal. Out of the gate I expected the RoMa Craft cigars to have a bit more bite than they had when they first launched (mostly due to Skip’s love for full-bodied, full-strength cigars), but was surprised with the more mild approach. It’s not a bad thing by any means as I’ve been a huge fan of each of the past sticks in their portfolio, but they delivered a powerhouse cigar with great balance, and bold flavors with the Neanderthal. This cigar comes out of the gate firing on all cylinders and doesn’t give up until your fingertips are burning. At $12 a pop it’s not the most affordable cigar out there, but it’s more than justified and very box worthy. Being that the Neanderthal is a full-production line I can see it having a permanent place in my regular rotation for a very long time. The Aquitaine has been my favorite RoMa Craft Tobac stick for a very long time, but it now has some competition. Now if we could just get them in a shop here locally, that would be great.

Full Review Here

#4 Illusione ~eccj~ 20th

Illusione ~eccj~ 20th

I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again. If I was forced to smoke only one brand for the rest of my life it would have to be Illusione. The ~eccj~ is a great example of an absolutely great cigar experience. The bold, complex, yet complimentary flavors provide an amazing profile with great construction and flawless burned all delivered at a decent price point. Yes, it’s one of the more expensive cigars in Illusione’s portfolio but it more than satisfies and I’d pay it time and time again. While the ~eccj~ is limited, it’s still widely available and this is a box-worthy purchase for sure as it would hold a place in my regular rotation for a very long time.

Full Review Here

#3 Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust – Sobremesa

Dunbarton Sobremesa

This is exactly what I expected as an introduction cigar by a very meticulous man who knows his shit. The Sobremesa delivers a full-bodied, medium/full strength cigar that doesn’t overpower you in any one direction. Add that with a very enjoyable, unique flavor profile and it’s easy to call Saka’s re-introduction a success. The price of the cigar isn’t too bad either making it an easy box-worthy decision. While they are a bit hard to obtain right now due to demand, expect these cigars to keep popping up in shops across the nation, and don’t hesitate to grab them when they do. You won’t regret it.

Full Review Here

#2 The Crowned Heads – Las Calaveras 2015

Crowned Heads Las Calaveras 2015

Let’s face it, The Crowned Heads are a force to be reckoned with. Here they are again kicking out yet another amazing blend. I was a big fan of last year’s Las Calaveras, but the 2015 blew last year’s out of the water. I know it’s still very, very early in the year but this is the best new release that I have had so far. I’m a big fan of bold cigars, and I am even a bigger fan of bold cigars that create amazing flavor profiles without being overloaded with strength. The Las Calaveras did just that. This is a great cigar that for a novice cigar smoker looking for a bold experience without breaking the bank, and a perfect cigar for those seasoned vets looking for a complex, bold experience. At a very affordable price point the only bad thing about this cigar is the availability. Believe me, I have quite a few on hand now and will be on the hunt for more. Get your hands on these while you can.

Full Review Here

#1 L’Atlier  – La Mission Du L’Atlier

La Mission Du L’Atelier

L’Atelier has made some great blends in the past, but they have outdone themselves with the La Mission which has quickly become my favorite release by them to date. The cigar is bold, complex, and just all around enjoyable at a damn good price. L’Atelier has become increasingly easier to track down as well. This is a perfect cigar for a novice looking for a perfect bold, premium cigar that won’t break the bank, and the seasoned cigar smoker who enjoys more full-bodied cigars, especially those who tend to pair their cigars with wine.

Full Review Here

Tony Casas is a 32 year old Creative Managing/Webdesigning/Craft Beer Drinking Cigar smoker from El Paso, Texas. When he isn’t loving his wife he is either sleepy, hungry, or suffering from a headache.

4 Comments

  1. Sam C.

    December 28, 2015 at 10:14 pm

    Tony,
    Great list. I always look forward to the Casas top ten, and it never disappoints. So, looks like I’ll need to seek out those Caldwells and the Undercrown Shade. Did you get a chance to try the Oktoberfest in the Das Brauhaus size? Looks like a flying pig, costs a third of it. Same Nicaraguan blend.
    Thanks for test driving these great cigars for us!

    • Tony Casas

      December 29, 2015 at 7:27 am

      I did have the Das Brqauhaus and rather enjoyed it, but I liked the format of the Double Bock a bit more. Not only the size, but I feel that the nicaraguan blend really shined with a smaller ring format letting you pick up more of the flavor nuances than the larger RG. Funny, I tend to almost always gravitate towards the smaller RG but in the traditional Dominican Oktoberfest I thought the 60×6 was the best size.

  2. Mark K

    January 1, 2016 at 12:08 pm

    Interesting list Tony. I have only had about half the cigars on your list. The one that your description has me wanting to try is the Oktoberfest. Sounds like it would be right up my alley.
    Enjoy your site. Keep smoking and reporting!!

  3. Charlie H.

    January 8, 2016 at 10:12 am

    This is the list closest to what I would consider my “top 10 of 2015″…literally spot on! Although my #1 would be the Tatuaje TAA ’15.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *